Optimism Community Call Recaps & Recordings Thread

Token House Call: June 4th, 2024

Recording here: June 4th, 2024 Token House Recording.mp4 - Google Drive
Slides: June 4th, 2024 Token House call slides

  • Both protocol upgrades, Fault Proofs and Guardian and Security Threshold Changes, and governor upgrade, Agora advanced delegation bug fixes in alligator, passed.
  • Grants Council and Advisory Developer Board were renewed.
    • There are 12 positions open for Grants Council: 12 mission reviewers (3 superchain, 9 optimism) 2 Audit & Special Mission Reviewers and 3 Milestones & Metrics Reviewers.
    • Advisory Developer Board has 5 positions open.
    • Election Town hall will be hosted on June 11th at 13:00 ET for Grants Council and 14:00 ET for Advisory Developer Board.
    • To see nominees: Grants Council | Developer Advisory Board
    • A forum post thread will be made on the 6th for any questions.
  • The Code of Conduct Council budget wasn’t renewed due to concerns around the budget, any prospective lead can propose a different budget in the forum by June 12th, it will go into vote in Voting Cycle 23b if approved. If the Code of Conduct Council is not renewed, the support nerds will continue to monitor the forum and enforce the rules of engagement.
  • There two upcoming votes in Voting Cycle 23b: Season 6: Chain Delegation Program Amendment and Season 6: Anticapture Commission Amendment
  • Upgrade Proposal #9: Fjord Network Upgrade:
    • RIP-7212 introduces a new pre-compile for the “secp256r1” elliptic curve.
    • Brotli as a new compression operation for batches, giving anywhere from 5 to 15, in some cases, 20% reduction in L1 data availability costs.
    • Lower data availability costs will be passed back to users through appropriate tuning of the revenue recovery parameters, it will vary depending on the chain operator.
    • FastLZ based L1 data fee function will more accurately charge for L1 data usage on a per transaction basis, resulting in more accurate pricing of transactions.
    • Chain operators now have 30 minutes instead of 10 to respond to L1 node outage issues before the L2 chain stalls.
    • The getL1GasUsed on the GasPriceOracle function updates immediately at the hard fork block. If the wallet is implemented correctly they will get the new value and everything will work as expected.
  • Retro Funding 4 sign ups end on Thursday, June 6th.
    • There was a call on Retro Funding round 4 for the Token House, the purpose of this call was to share context between houses and give a better understanding on Retro Funding overall.
  • We had Griff Green talking about Pairwise, a community signaling app, aimed to decentralize and expand the citizen’s house.
    • Everyone can vote on retro funding, not just badgeholders.

    • Creates four different voting results and see how they would have distributed retro funding.

    • It will be pseudonymous and mobile, and people will be able to choose categories of projects to vote on.

    • It will show proposals using a Tinder like system, showing all the details and you get to decide whether you like the proposal or not. After that the Pairwise system will show all the metrics and details submitted to the proposal, get final results and create a final ranking.

    • You also will be able to comment on proposals and give feedback.

    • Anyone who participates has the chance to win a 100 OP. There will be 40 people who win a 100 OP.

    • Read Pairwise: Community Signaling in Retro Funding 4 - No badge required for more details and leave feedback.

4 Likes

Joint House Call: June 18th, 2024

Recording: June 18th, 2024 Joint House Call Recording.mp4 - Google Drive
Slides: June 18th, joint house call slides

  • Ratification of profit definition for Round 4: 30 random citizens were selected to take part in the deliberative process to determine the profit definition in Round 4.
    • The way the basic formula works is you have the amount of impact that’s been generated, then the profit or the past transfers is subtracted, and that would be the award in OP. The first session that the participants voted on which of the categories (Optimism grants, venture funding, grants that come from other ecosystems, and revenue) they thought should be included in the profit definition. Results determined that a deduction weight would only be applied only to Optimism Grants.
    • The second vote was on the deduction weight that should be applied to Optimism grants, which was divided into three categories: 10% deduction for Token House Growth Grants, 25% deduction for Token House Builders Grants and a 45% deduction for Foundation Grants. Retro Funding is not included.
    • If the profit part (past transfers) is higher than the impact, the Retro Funding reward will be zero, there won’t be any negative rewards.
    • If the definition is ratified it will be globally and automatically applied to the voting result calculation in Round 4, and it will only be applied to Round 4. If not, a fallback definition proposed by the Foundation will be globally and automatically applied to the voting result calculation in Round 4 instead.
    • Voting will take place on Snapshot and will run from June 20-26 at 19:00 GMT.
  • Retro Funding 4: Application Review Process:
    • The purpose of this process is to make sure all applications comply with the application rules and with the eligibility criteria.
    • All reviews will be done by June 20th 19:00 GMT, everyone that was rejected has the can hand in an appeal if they don’t agree with the decision.
  • Retro Funding 4 Voting:
    • Voting UI is up for everyone to test, if you discover any issue report them in the Retro Funding Discord channel: Voting UI Retro Funding 4
    • The voting will be via metrics, badgeholders will be able to see and choose from a selection of 60 metrics which measure different types of impact, the way work is that you select the metrics that you want to reward, the kind of impact you want to reward, and weigh them in your ballot. You will be able to see how they impact the distribution of OP among projects and then you will be able to submit your votes.
    • To know more about how these metrics were created: Retro Funding 4: Impact Metrics, a Collective Experiment
    • Voting starts June 27th until July 10th.
  • Foundation Year 3 Budget Update: the Foundation is requesting zero additional OP, so there will not be a Token House vote on this budget as no OP is being requested.
  • Round 4 Bribery Policy: report any verifiable instance of bribery using the form linked here. All discussions and reports should be in accordance with the Rules of Engagement.
  • Code of Conduct Council Operating budget re-scope: Delegates will vote again for a Code of Conduct Council Operating Budget in Special Voting Cycle #23b.
    • Nominations must be posted on this thread by 19:00 GMT on Thursday, June 27th.
3 Likes

Token House Call: July 2nd, 2024

Recording: July 2 Token House Call recording.mp4
Alternate recording (includes Jing’s slides): tl;dv - app
Slides: July 2nd, 2024 Token House call slides

2 Likes

Joint House Call: July 16th, 2024

Recording: Joint House Call July 16, 2024 Superchain Strategy.mp4 - Google Drive
Alternate recording: tl;dv - app
Jing’s Slides: Optimism Governance Community Call_July 2024 .pdf - Google Drive

5 Likes

@Michael, I loved watching the call! Would it be possible to see the slides? The recording didn’t include them. TY!

Hey! Thankfully @dmars300 made a recording as well that has the slides: tl;dv - app.

3 Likes

Token House Call: August 6th, 2024

Recording: August 6th 2024 Token House Call Recording.mp4 - Google Drive
Slides: August 6th, 2024 Token House call slides - Google Slides

6 Likes

Joint House Call: August 15th, 2024

Slides:August 13th, 2024 Joint House call slides

Recording:vme-ovto-jcn (2024-08-13 20:02 GMT+2)

Big thank you to @Jrocki for hosting while I was in the jungles of Nicaragua!

  • Security Council nominations are due August 14th 19:00 GMT, nominees need 8 delegates approvals by August 19th.
  • Cycle 25 Grants roundup:
    • 50 applications received and managed to review 100% of them at each milestone.
    • Applications not approved will be carried over to the next cycle for additional review by three more Grants Council members.
    • Check out the grants you can apply for here. How to apply tutorial here.
    • Detailed scores: Grants Council public database.
    • Superchains grants are only going to be applicable for chains that are live, and the max amount they can request is 1M OP.
    • Shout-out to the DAB for the amazing feedback and to everyone that has applied for the high quality of the applications :slightly_smiling_face:
  • Scale ENS to OP | Blockful – Official ENS Service Provider:
  • Anticapture Commission with web3magetic:
    • ACC is internally discussing the voting UI bug that delegates had in the last voting cycle and brainstorming ideas on ways to decentralize voting.
  • Retro Funding 5: OP Stack:
    • Sign up: August 15th - August 29th | Application Review Process: August 30th - September 13th | Voting: September 14th - September 28th | Results & Grant delivery: October 3rd
    • Eligibility Criteria: Ethereum Core Contributions | OP Stack Research & Development | OP Stack Tooling
    • This round’s budget is set by the Foundation (8M OP), the budget for round 6 and 7 will be set by the Citizens’ House.
  • Retro Funding 5: Expert voting experiment:
    • People’s expertise that apply to be a guest voter will be measured based on their past Github activity related to the OP Stack. There will be more details on how the expertise will be measured in the next Joint House call.
    • There will be three voter groups: Badgeholders with expertise (25 people), Badgeholder without expertise as control group and will be selected via random sampling (50 people) and Guest voters with expertise.
    • Voters will be announced at the end of August.
6 Likes

Token House Call: August 27th, 2024

Recording: august_27_2024_token_house_call

Slides: August 27th, 2024 Token House call slides

  • Upgrade Proposal #10: Granite Network Upgrade:
    • This upgrade is proposed in response to security vulnerabilities identified during a series of third-party security audits and lower severity issues will be planned in future upgrades.
    • The specification for the proposed changes can be found in the specs repo.
    • This upgrade resets user withdrawals. Any proof submissions within the last 7 days from the upgrade will be invalid and they will have to resubmit the proofs.
    • If you have any questions about this upgrade there will be office hours this Thursday at 14:00, check the OP Governance calendar.
  • Proposal Title: Rolling Mission Requests
    • This proposal requests that the Token House allow the Grants Council to create and submit rolling Mission Requests, using unallocated budget from Intent 3A. These Requests will focus on initiatives that directly contribute to Intent 3A and will be subject to full approval by the Token House.
  • Retro Funding 5: Application Form Changes
    • Organizations were introduced in order to assess the issue of having individual applications overloaded with too many different projects.
    • individuals can still submit their project application as normally.
  • Retro Funding 5: Grants & Funding within the application process
    • Projects applying for Retro Funding 5 will be required to report grants received from the Optimism Foundation, Token House or Citizens’ House since January 2023, funding received in exchange for equity since January 2020 and if their product/service it’s paid projects will be asked to report the pricing model for their product/service.
    • Other grants and revenue are not verifiable so there’s no need to report those.
  • Superchain Grants Review Process
    • Every proposal will be evaluated based on 15 yes/no questions.
    • Only live chains will be considered.
    • Grant cap is set at 3M OP, the hard cap is the limit not the standard grant size.
  • Cycle 26 Grants Preliminary Review Report
  • Voting Cycle Roundup #26
    • Remember to submit your votes on Upgrade Proposal #10: Granite Network Upgrade and Security Council Lead before August 28th 19:00 GMT.
    • Security Council members voting ends September 1st, quorum has not been reached yet.

The Code of conduct council just published its Internal Operating procedures. The first Office Hours will be August 29th at 10:00 ET.

5 Likes

Joint House Call: September 10th, 2024

Recording: September 10th, Joint House Call recording
Slides: September 10th, Joint House Call slides

  • Upcoming Proposals:
    • Upcoming cycles will feature proposals to move the GovFund on-chain, allowing intent budgets to be transferred to the Grants Council or relevant managers. Agora will post a draft to support that.
    • There will be a post clarifying how the superchain registry, blockspace charters, log chains, and interop fit together, and their timelines.
    • On-chain execution and Blockspace Charter ratification will happen before the end of Season 6, with enough information provided for voting.
  • Retro Funding 6: Guest Voter Participation with Emily:
    • Currently there are two cohorts of voters that were selected with a specific selection method: Citizens that were selected via Web of Trust and Round 5 Guest Voters that were selected via Proof of Work.
    • In Retro Funding 6, 100 randomly selected guest voters will be introduced, forming a control group. These voters will need to complete a survey to participate.
    • Stakeholders across the collective will blind vote on resource allocations to determine which group’s decisions are better, without knowing which group made the decision.
    • The goal is to understand if specific selection mechanisms, such as web of trust or proof of work, produce different outcomes than random selection.
    • There will be a mentorship program in Round 6, but due to scaling limitations, only half of the guest voters will receive onboarding to test its effectiveness.
    • Citizens will have a fail-safe option in Round 6 to reduce the voting power of guest voters if any signs of collusion are detected.
  • Impact Metrics Garden:
    • The project collects standardized qualitative data from core OP Stack developers, delegates, and users through on-chain reviews.
    • Reviews focus on how users would feel if the contribution didn’t exist, offering valuable insights to badge holders for making funding allocation decisions.
    • Impact Garden is not officially part of the rounds but serves as an additional tool for evaluating and showcasing contributions within the Optimism ecosystem.
    • metricsgarden.xyz
  • Cycle 26 Grants Final Roundup:
    • 29 new applications in Cycle 26, along with 24 applications carried over from the previous cycle.
    • List of applications.
  • Retro Funding 5 applications are closed! Check all projects here: retrolist.app
  • Foundation Mission Request are open and looking for applicants:
  • If you want to show your project you can go to Discord and apply to be in the Demo Day: Demo Day Discord Channel
  • If you are a delegate or a badgeholder go check DeVouch, a simple tool to vouch for or flag projects.
  • There is going to be a Workshop by Token Engineering Academy: GovXS - OP Retro Funding Voting Design Evaluation – Foundation Mission Request #188 – Badgeholder Workshop. Monday, September 23, at 17:00 UTC
  • See the Mission Request ranking for Cycle 27 here: Cycle 27 MR List
13 Likes

Thanks Michael for creating this go to thread for us.

3 Likes

Thanks for putting in the effort to summarize and share the key updates for the September 10th Joint House Call! Your work helps keep us all connected, informed, and excited for what’s ahead. We appreciate your dedication in making the governance process more accessible and engaging for everyone!

2 Likes

Came in a bit late, thanks for the recap. Will there be a specific thread to answer questions about the call?

1 Like

Hey @yellowflash you can make your questions on here :raised_hands:t2:

1 Like

I was referring to this lol :sweat_smile:

1 Like

Ohh sorry, you can do it in the thread directly:

I see you did, congrats!!

Token House Call: September 24th, 2024

Recording: September 24th, Token House Call recording
Slides: September 24th, Token House Call slides

  • Retro Funding 6: Governance - Round details:
    • Sign up starts on September 26th until October 28th.
    • The Foundation is assigning a minimum OP Amount for the round of 1.1M OP and a maximum OP amount of 3.5m OP. Citizens will be able to vote for an OP amount within the range of minimum and maximum which they believe appropriately rewards the impact within the round.
  • Retro Funding 5: Application Review Process & Round Sizing Update:
    • You can find the results here, including reason for rejection from the reviewers.
    • Citizens will vote on the round’s OP allocation within the rounds voting experience. The Foundation is assigning a minimum OP Amount for the round of 2M OP and a maximum OP amount of 8m OP, the initial token allocation was of 8M OP. The voting process will start on September 30th.
  • Cycle 27 Grants final roundup:
  • Cycle 28 Grants Council Audits implementation:
    • This new process aims to streamline audit requests by enabling eligible auditors to directly apply for specific audits, drawing from the mission request budget without the need for pre-approved budgets. Read the forum forum post for more information on how it works.
  • Accelerated Decentralization Proposal For Optimism & Foundation response:
    • This proposal suggests transferring governance control from the Foundation and OP Labs.
    • This plan is divided into three phases of decentralization, to be completed by summer of 2025.
      • Phase I: involves transferring ownership of the OP token contract, governance contract, and governance fund, along with 15,397 ETH collected for the benefit of Optimism governance, to governance control.
      • Phase II: will transition control of the L1 Bridge escrow to governance and introduce a roadmap for decentralizing the sequencer. The Law of Chains will also be revised by governance.
      • Phase III: will complete the decentralization, transferring full control over the Optimism protocol to Token House, Citizen’s House, and other governance bodies, alongside disclosures of all Foundation grants and full sequencer decentralization.
    • This is not a governance vote, you can signal your approval on this Snapshot petition. This is meant to help inform the Foundation on the level of support for these items as they prepare their own plan to present.
    • The Foundation reaffirmed its commitment to gradual, secure decentralization, emphasizing a long-term approach over speed. It agrees with the need for full decentralization but emphasizes that this process must be done carefully and gradually to ensure the system’s long-term security and resilience.
    • During the community call, many participants shared their opinions and concerns on this topic; this is an ongoing discussion so all citizens are encouraged to read both the proposal and the Foundation’s response, and share their thoughts! :slightly_smiling_face:
5 Likes

Joint House Call: October 8th, 2024

Recording: October 8th, 2024 joint house recording.mp4 - Google Drive
Slides: October 8th, 2024 Joint House call slides - Google Slides

  • Retro Funding 6: Governance - Round details
    • Retro Funding 6 applications close October 14th 19:00 UTC and voting will start October 28th.
    • Read the forum post for more details about the categories, if you have any questions feel free to comment them in that post or in the Restro Funding Discord channel.
    • Citizens will vote on the allocation of OP for the round within some minimums and maximums set by the foundation.
    • The voting design and experience itself will be pretty much what voters are currently experiencing in round five.
  • Retro Funding 6: Impact Attestation experiment
    • The Collective will experiment with collecting data on the impact of different governance contributions for the “Governance Infrastructure & Tooling” category via attestations, the top 100 Delegates, Citizens and governance leadership functions will be asked to participate.
    • All projects that apply through OP Atlas will be shown automatically in the Metrics Garden platform. No need for additional applications.
    • It’s important that anyone leaving a review links the wallet that has their badgeholder attestation. Votes and comments will be public.
    • This experiment will run from the 14ht to the 23rd.
  • Retro Funding 6: Application Review Process
    • Citizens can opt-in to participate in the application review process until Oct 11th 19:00 UTC. To opt-in fill out this form
    • If you are applying with your own project to the round, you should not apply to the reviewer.
  • Retro Funding 5: Self-Dealing Policy
    • You may report any verifiable instance of a conflict of interest rule violation using the form linked here. Reports can be submitted up to Dec 18th.
    • Badgeholders are required to disclose any conflicts of interest during project reviews. These conflicts of interest will be public.
  • Decentralization of Governance and Superchain Product Vision
    • More information will be released next Tuesday and there is going to be a discussion about it.
    • Season 7 planning will start in November so the community can be more involved.
    • There is going to be a session with Jing to walk through the product vision and how that relates to the intents for season 7.
  • Cycle 28 Grants Preliminary Roundup
    • A total of 53 applications, which included Superchain and audit applications.
    • If you need an audit, be sure to check out the Audits Hub
    • Cycle 28 GC’s database with all the finalist
  • Collective Feedback Commission Pilot Retrospective
    • This pilot exceeded the goals set!
    • Season 7 will convert the Commission into a persistent structure, complete with a Charter and Lead.
    • The next iteration is expected to launch in early November.
  • Optimism Fractal’s one year anniversary!
    • We had Dan Singjoy sharing updates and announcements for Optimism Fractal one year anniversary, inviting everyone to check their website, and learn about their weekly events. They host every Thursday at 17 UTC that everybody’s welcome to join.
    • Check these slides for more information
  • The Code of Conduct Council just published its mid-season report. All invited to read it and comment. Code of Conduct Council accountability reports S6
6 Likes

Token House Call: October 22nd, 2024

Recording: October 22nd, Token House Call
Slides: October 22nd, Token House Call

4 Likes