If you are active here and/or on discord, you might have seen some discussion on Public Good. I have been thinking about it and in last few days, after reading, learning and discussion within my circle, my definition of Public Good has changed a lot.
I have came to realization that its scope is much bigger than I initially thought and when we add RPGF to it, its gets more complex.
What is public good.
By definition public good can be anything that has two properties, non-rivel in consumption and non-excludable[1].
Non-rivel in consumption:- If I consume the good, it must not have any effect on other’s opportunity to cosume the same good.
Non-exludable:- We can not deny each other the opportunity to consume the good.
Another defination that I like “Public goods are “…things [that] do not lend themselves to [private] production, purchase and sale. They must be provided for everyone if they are to be provided for anyone, and they must be paid forcollectively or they cannot be had at all.” [2]
There has be different thoughts on Open Source Software, by definition Open Source Software, OSS is a public good[3] but only and only if the complete code is issued under open source license agreement[4], to extend this, the license should falls under Free Software Foundation (FSF) GNU, GPL, or GNU LGPL licenses, which ensure that the source code of software can be copied, modified, distributed freely and that – most importantly – all derived work has to be under the same open source license (FSF (2004))] [5]
Knowledge is a public good[6] too but it depends on how you choose to use it.
Other example would be someone or group of people translating complete Optimism related documentation in their local language such as Chinese or Japanese.
Lighthouse is an another example, once built its available freely to all the sailors.
What is public good to you ? If you could provide your view with one example it would help us all.
I also want to touch RPGF quickly and here I will focus only on Ethereum and Optimism ecosystem, anything(individual/group of people/project) that is publicly available and has a positive impact on the ecosystem is a candidate for RPGF.
Impact is the key word, in my opinion, when we talk RPGF to public good and to give you an example, candide-wallet will be an OSS which is a public good but its not a candidate for RPGF as its not live yet, hence no impact. What is your view here? How you see public good and RPGF.?
TL;DR:- What is public good to you?
Note: I have permission from @marc to use his proposal as a reference.
- https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/stantcheva/files/lecture8.pdf
- https://www.bu.edu/eci/files/2019/10/PublicGoods.pdf
- https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/49926/1/668836490.pdf
- https://www.uky.edu/~drag222/research/Agrawal_OSS.pdf
- https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/49926/1/668836490.pdf
- https://www.uky.edu/~drag222/research/Agrawal_OSS.pdf
Edit 1:- Added Tl;dr