Hello!
Trying to make this a habit; I share here the reasoning behind my votes in the Special Voting Cycle #31a
Proposals I voted in favor of:
Treasury Transfer
- Onchain Treasury Transfer Test
- Onchain Treasury Transfer Cancellation Test
→ While I’m not entirely clear on the process, I consider it safe enough to experiment.
Upgrade
- Upgrade Proposal #11: Holocene Network Upgrade
→ I didn’t think the upgrade brought any risks or dangers that would warrant stopping it.
Season 7 Intent
- Season 7: Intent Ratification
→ I accept the intent defined for this season, and I celebrate that it is only one (since it promotes greater focus and synergy).
ACC
- Season 7: Anticapture Commission Amendment
→ I recognize the value of the ACC but I wonder how static the group of top 100 delegates is. How do we prevent it from solidifying into a power group? How do we promote rotation?
Season 7 Operating Budgets
- Season 7: Grants Council Operating Budget
- Season 7: Developer Advisory Board Operating Budget
- Season 7: Milestones and Metrics Council Operating Budget
- Season 7: Security Council Operating Budget [Onchain]
→ I attended the Budgets Discussion by L2BEATS and it seems to me that there is a lot of reasoning behind each of these proposals, and I trust their judgment.
My only observation is the difference in the range of amounts selected for the compensation of certain roles. I think it would be very valuable if it was better justified where it comes from compared to the value that that profile has in the market or any other process they have done to arrive at that amount.
COCC
- Code of Conduct Council Dissolution Proposal
→ Having been a member of the Code of Conduct Council, I support this proposal for dissolution as it seems to me that a representative structure is not the best way to promote the rules of engagement.
Proposals I abstained from:
- Decision Market Mission [Onchain]
→ While I find the experiment interesting (and it could bring a lot of value to the collective), I find it confusing to understand why this amount comes from the governance fund and is not considered a mission of the foundation (especially if it is work carried out by external actors). I think more information needs to be shared, so I do not feel comfortable adding to the quorum.
Proposals I voted against:
- N/A