Airdrop #5 Feedback Thread

I decided to create this thread on the forum by analogy with the previous Airdrop threads.

In addition, I have questions about the conditions for receiving this drop.
It would be good if those who implemented the selection of addresses answered these questions:

  1. Do I understand correctly that Bonus Rewards are taken into account only in combination with Base Rewards? That is, if a user has several Bonus Rewards, but there are no conditions for Base Rewards, then the user will not receive anything?
  2. Were there any address exclusions for any other requirements (sanctions, blacklists, amount of funds, etc.)?
  3. What should users do who are sure that they meet the official requirements, but their addresses are not on the list?

1 Like

This Drop #5 is disappointing from a governance perspective:

=By setting a delegation bonus criteria without factoring in the activity of the chosen delegate, we’re basically telling people, "Delegate once, pick anyone, and forget about it. " I see people flagged as “active_delegator” who delegated to delegates that NEVER vote and of course there’s no incentive to change if you reward them for it.

= The discoverability of delegate activity on the Agora platform is almost non-existent. The fact that the foundation doesn’t promote alternative sources of delegate visibility during massive delegation events like airdrops is very disappointing.

During this drop 5, a new cohort of OP holders will once again delegate their voting power to inactive delegates. How disappointing, What a missed opportunity…

4 Likes

Hey the Base rewards calculation are wrong when compared to blockchain data or there is a blacklist. Example: 0x8feafd5e0fcefdd2624906c0f913d563306aae17

This wallet is mine: it should have gotten airdrop using OP criteria, around 3500 OP, it wasn’t eligible.

HAS yet to see the code they used to calculate this for all wallets from OP side.

I haven’t seen a blacklist but I am suspected these exists as all active wallets linked to my main hot wallet didn’t get anything whilst wallets I use on another network, phone etc. All got the airdrop despite having little to none on chain activity besides supporting my Bot wallets

1 Like

@system Tell us, do you have any information about whether there is a blacklist for the airdrop?

I understand that maybe you can’t disclose it, but users have a problem that no one can help them with except you

The second issue is about delegates, which was voiced by @latruite.eth .
Indeed, in the future it is necessary to take into account active delegates, and not just delegations to nowhere

1 Like