I’m casting a “FOR” vote on the Budget Board Charter. I’m not wild about the current draft, but having something in place is still better than what we’ve lived with.
Here’s what I wish had made it into the charter:
1. More community voice in seat selection
Right now the Charter lets the Foundation hand-pick the entire Genesis cohort (and possibly future cohorts). Instead, I would’ve suggested:
-
Hybrid intake: Foundation nominates one member per House, the rest filled through open elections.
-
Cap insider seats and publish a clear scoring rubric so the Board feels earned, not appointed.
2. A roadmap to community-authored Mission scopes
Even with a community budget board, the Foundation still writes every Mission scope. Instead, I would’ve suggested:
- Sunset OKR: by the end of Season 9, at least 30 % of Mission scopes must originate from delegates or the Board; majority community authorship by Season 10.
Appreciate everyone’s work so far; let’s keep iterating towards decentralization.