[REVIEW][GF Phase 1 Proposal] Optimism 🤝 Tally Ho

[mhluongo]

Hey @krzkaczor! I appreciate the work you guys are doing here, and I know this season is tight. Thank you for the time you’ve all put in here.

@krzkaczor

In the same line of Ambire Wallet’s proposal, our final recommendation comes from the fact, that as has been pointed out on the forum - there are many proposals approaching user incentivisation using OP rewards, but there is no common framework for user rewards structure across different projects. It would be unfair if the reward structure differed between projects, so we suggest delaying any further grants toward user incentivisation in wallets until such a framework is formed.

It does indeed seem unfair that the other wallet that shared a proposal after we did — Rainbow — was recommended. Would it make sense if we used the same incentives they did, with the same KPIs? Or is there a reason that structure doesn’t make sense for other wallets?

@krzkaczor

After that, each wallet asking for a grant toward user incentivisation should follow this framework of rewards structure.

If we believe Rainbow’s incentive structure is ideal, perhaps we already have a framework… a
pave the cow paths" situation.

@krzkaczor

Furthermore, we recommend separating the work for integrating the wallet with specific dapps into another proposal, so that this aspect can be voted separately.

This was recommended against by a couple delegates we’ve spoken to, but happy to make this change if it makes more sense to the committee!