Thanks for putting this together @ACC!
A few questions:
-
If individual member votes are collected in a private telegram poll, how will the community be able to verify that the ACC is casting its vote in accordance with the outcome of internal votes? Or does this just replace a redundant internal process but the public vote still must be cast with a majority of signatures?
-
In The Future of the Anticapture Commission, you raise concerns around the concentration of power among participating delegates. In this retrospective, you propose reducing the number of participating delegates from ~26 to ~12. Wouldn’t this exacerbate the power dynamics among participants?
-
In terms of your suggestions for paths forward for the ACC, we would recommend “streamlining the ACC into a ‘call-when-needed’ body” if the ACC is to continue. It’s important to note that assigning the ACC rights to cancel proposals, or other changes that alter the control structure and/or metagovernance parameters of the Collective, are not currently within scope.